Hardback : HK$985.00
In this timely study, Dawes defends the methodological naturalism of the sciences. Though religions offer what appear to be explanations of various facts about the world, the scientist, as scientist, will not take such proposed explanations seriously. Even if no natural explanation were available, she will assume that one exists. Is this merely a sign of atheistic prejudice, as some critics suggest? Or are there good reasons to exclude from science explanations that invoke a supernatural agent? On the one hand, Dawes concedes the bare possibility that talk of divine action could constitute a potential explanation of some state of affairs, while noting that the conditions under which this would be true are unlikely ever to be fulfilled. On the other hand, he argues that a proposed explanation of this kind would rate poorly, when measured against our usual standards of explanatory virtue.
In this timely study, Dawes defends the methodological naturalism of the sciences. Though religions offer what appear to be explanations of various facts about the world, the scientist, as scientist, will not take such proposed explanations seriously. Even if no natural explanation were available, she will assume that one exists. Is this merely a sign of atheistic prejudice, as some critics suggest? Or are there good reasons to exclude from science explanations that invoke a supernatural agent? On the one hand, Dawes concedes the bare possibility that talk of divine action could constitute a potential explanation of some state of affairs, while noting that the conditions under which this would be true are unlikely ever to be fulfilled. On the other hand, he argues that a proposed explanation of this kind would rate poorly, when measured against our usual standards of explanatory virtue.
Acknowledgments
Chapter 1: Against Religious Explanations
Chapter 2: On Explanations in General
Chapter 3: What are Theistic Explanations?
Chapter 4: What Would They Explain?
Chapter 5: Potential Theistic Explanations
Chapter 6: Inference to the Best Explanation
Chapter 7: Successful Theistic Explanations
Chapter 8: Conclusion
Appendix: Intentional Explanations
Notes
Bibliography
Index
Gregory W. Dawes is Associate Professor of Religious Studies at the University of Otago. He is the author of The Historical Jesus Question: The Challenge of History to Religious Authority.
Gregory Dawes' Theism and Explanation is a competent, nuanced look
at the nature and scope of theistic explanations. Dawes argues that
theistic explanations can in principle be good explanations, but he
also argues that they have to meet a high bar to count as good
explanations. ... The result is an interesting and insightful look
at what it takes to be a successful theistic explanation.
-Bradley Monton, University of Colorado at Boulder, Notre Dame
Philosophical Reviews
|
Ask a Question About this Product More... |
|
